Free Consultation: 949-222-0166
Some Good News!
Most years, the California Legislature hands down a plethora of new laws that negatively impact employers and increase the already high risk of liability in the Golden State. On very rare occasions, a new law comes along that actually benefits employers. At long last, the Legislature and Governor have enacted important changes to the California Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), which offer significant reductions in potential liability for employers that choose to take advantage of these new options.
History of PAGA
By way of background, PAGA was enacted in 2004 and imposed huge potential monetary penalties on employers who did not cross every single “T” and dot every single “I” with respect to the hundreds of California wage and hour laws. The Legislature’s supposed intention was to encourage employers to do a better job of complying with these laws or risk very expensive fines and penalties. The reality, however, was that while “aggrieved employees” only received a very nominal percentage of these monies, a fertile cottage industry was created by which plaintiffs’ attorneys got rich (or richer) and the State’s coffers were exponentially increased, all at the expense of California employers of every size and type. No one was immune.
In short, PAGA allowed almost any current or former employee to hire an attorney (at no cost to the employee) to file a lawsuit seeking PAGA penalties on behalf of every employee and former employee in the prior 12 months, not just the individual employee. The typical PAGA lawsuit alleged that the targeted employer violated multiple legal mandates, such as failing to provide all, fully compliant rest breaks, failing to provide all, fully compliant meal periods, failing to provide pay stubs with all the required, fully accurate information, failing to properly pay non-exempt employees, and many other such claims.
Under PAGA, employers were subject to penalties of $200 per employee per pay period for each such violation. By way of example, an employer with just five employees that paid employees every two weeks could be sued for about $24,000 for meal period violations plus $24,000 for rest break violations plus $24,000 for pay stub violations plus several other penalties, interest and attorneys fees. To illustrate who this law really benefited, and assuming just one $24,000 penalty, the attorney would typically receive approximately $10,000, the State would typically receive approximately $10,000 and the remaining $4,000 would be divided among the five employees (approximately $800 to each), who were also responsible for paying taxes on the payments. Clearly, the attorneys and the State were the true beneficiaries of PAGA, not the employees and certainly not the employers.
Hundreds of thousands of California employers were compelled to defend themselves against PAGA claims. Employers who thought they were paying their employees completely accurately, and even generously, were hit hard. For example, in your workplace, does every (non-exempt) employee get a 10-minute rest break mid-morning and mid-afternoon? Does every (non-exempt) employee begin their lunch break before they have finished the first five hours of work? If the answer to either question is “not always,” then that automatically means the company is liable for rest break, meal period and pay stub violations.
Needless to say, PAGA has been a nightmare for California employers.
The Anti-PAGA 2024 Ballot Initiative
It took almost twenty years, but finally, employer groups banded together, raised over 30 million dollars, and succeeded in getting an initiative qualified for the November 2024 ballot that would have repealed PAGA and replaced it with a far more fair and balanced penalty scheme. Most notably, the initiative required that 100% of the penalties be distributed to the employees, and prohibited any portion of the penalties going to either the attorneys or the State.
Of course, no one knew whether the initiative to repeal PAGA would pass in November, but the risk of losing scared the parties on every side of the issue enough to finally bring them together to reach a resolution. Thus, a PAGA compromise was born, molded, and eventually accepted on a bipartisan basis. PAGA reform legislation was enacted, and went into effect immediately, on July 1, 2024.
The PAGA Compromise
To be clear, PAGA remains a very real threat to the financial health of virtually every California employer. For example, PAGA penalties decreased from $200 per employee per pay period to $100 per employee per pay period, which is a very significant improvement, but even at $100 per employee per pay period per violation means that the threat of significant financial penalties is still alive and well.
Most importantly, the PAGA compromise provides a vehicle for employers to preemptively and exponentially reduce potential PAGA penalties:
So, what does “all reasonable steps to comply” mean? Under the new law, it includes:
Act Now, Do Not Wait!
California employers are strongly encouraged to take advantage of this opportunity to get their wage and hour houses in order, sooner rather than later. Work with one of our highly qualified employment attorneys to: (1) ensure that you have current, fully compliant, well-written policies; (2) conduct a payroll audit in order to identify and correct any potential violations; and (3) train yourselves, as well as any leads, supervisors, managers, and any others who may assist you with payroll.
It is not often that California employers get a break from the Legislature. Take advantage of this one and act now, do not wait!
Disclaimer: The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.
Copyright
All Rights Reserved | Scott & Whitehead | Powered By Convert It Marketing | Privacy Policy
Copyright
All Rights Reserved | Scott & Whitehead | Powered By Convert It Marketing | Privacy Policy